FAQ15

DNA for Germanic Genealogists

What DNA test is most popular for Germanic ancestry?
DNA testing got off to a slow start in Germany but this has been changing recently. Most DNA experts agree that MyHeritage has the most German participants, but Ancestry and 23andMe are also viable options.

Why are my DNA ethnicity results so strange?
Ethnicity estimates attempt to explain where in the world your DNA came from. Of course, your DNA is not neatly labeled with stickers saying “Made in Pakistan” or “Made in the USA” like clothing at the store. So how do genetic testing companies know where your ancestors were living 5 or more generations ago?

The short answer is: They don’t. Not for sure anyway.

But DNA testing companies make guesses – sometimes very good guesses, sometimes less accurate guesses – by comparing your DNA with DNA from reference populations. A reference population is a group of testers who can confidently say all four of their grandparents or all eight of their greatgrandparents were from a specific locality. If a section of your DNA is most similar to the reference population from Wales, for example, then that section of DNA will be identified as Welsh. The testing
company makes these kinds of matches for all your DNA and then reports to you the percentages.

Your ethnicity estimate may not match expected results due to

• an error in your paper tree or a non-paternal event
• poor quality reference panels. If the DNA testing company does not have good representation from a given place, then the portion of a tester’s DNA which is actually from that place may be labeled with a place for which the company does have representation. (This should become less and less of an issue as testing companies’ databases grow and their algorithms improve, etc.).
• genetic recombination. A full explanation of this biological process will not be attempted in this short space. Suffice it to say that an individual does not inherit DNA from ALL their ancestors. You may not have inherited DNA from all 32 of your 4x great-grandparents. So if you did not inherit genetic material from ancestors who came from a given place, your ethnicity estimate will not point to that locality. Again, even though you can trace your line to that locality on paper, you may not have inherited genetic material that is traceable to that locality.

To hear industry expert Diahan Southard explain ethnicity estimates in just under ten minutes, check out
this video from RootsTech 2021.